Applicant Tracking (ATS)
5 qualifying programs compared.
Compare inside a category, not across the study. Two programs here face the same buyers and the same norms, so a difference between them means something. A difference between categories mostly measures the categories.
| Axis | Ashby | iCIMS | Greenhouse | Lever | Workday Recruiting |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Overall | 40.95 axes | 35.95 axes | 35.55 axes | 34.15 axes | 19.56 axes |
| Transparency | 1.3 | 1.3 | 1.9 | 1.3 | 0.5 |
| Demand | 1.5 | 0.0 | 1.5 | 0.0 | 1.0 |
| Entry cost | 3.0 | 2.5 | 3.0 | 3.0 | 2.5 |
| Distribution | 2.5 | 2.5 | 1.0 | 2.0 | 1.0 |
| Economics | not applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing | not applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing | not applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing | not applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing | 0.0 |
| Terms | 2.5 | 2.5 | 2.5 | 2.5 | 2.5 |
n/athe axis does not apply to that program — read it as “question not asked”, never as 0.
These programs are judged on different numbers of axes, so their totals are renormalized over different denominators and are not strictly comparable. The axis rows are.
Where they actually differ
14 of 30 checks diverge; 16 are identical across all 5| Check | Ashby | iCIMS | Greenhouse | Lever | Workday Recruiting |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A1 Guide public | published, and we read it | published, and we read it | published, and we read it | published, and we read it | partly published |
| A2 Requirements numeric | we looked for it and it is not published | we looked for it and it is not published | partly published | we looked for it and it is not published | we looked for it and it is not published |
| A3 Reward numeric | not applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing, so there are no economics to publish | not applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing, so there are no economics to publish | not applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing, so there are no economics to publish | not applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing, so there are no economics to publish | we looked for it and it is not published |
| B1 Lead share | we looked for it and it is not published | we looked for it and it is not published | partly published | we looked for it and it is not published | we looked for it and it is not published |
| B3 Co-marketing specified | published, and we read it | we looked for it and it is not published | partly published | we looked for it and it is not published | partly published |
| B5 Merchandising | partly published | we looked for it and it is not published | partly published | we looked for it and it is not published | partly published |
| C3 Fast review | partly published | partly published | published, and we read it | partly published | partly published |
| C5 No paid tier gate | published, and we read it | partly published | partly published | published, and we read it | partly published |
| D4 Listing control | partly published | partly published | we looked for it and it is not published | partly published | we looked for it and it is not published |
| D5 Audience disclosed | published, and we read it | published, and we read it | we looked for it and it is not published | partly published | we looked for it and it is not published |
| E2 They collect and remit | not applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing, so there are no economics to publish | not applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing, so there are no economics to publish | not applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing, so there are no economics to publish | not applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing, so there are no economics to publish | we looked for it and it is not published |
| E3 You set the price | not applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing, so there are no economics to publish | not applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing, so there are no economics to publish | not applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing, so there are no economics to publish | not applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing, so there are no economics to publish | we looked for it and it is not published |
| E4 Provisioning documented | not applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing, so there are no economics to publish | not applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing, so there are no economics to publish | not applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing, so there are no economics to publish | not applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing, so there are no economics to publish | we looked for it and it is not published |
| E5 Payout terms published | not applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing, so there are no economics to publish | not applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing, so there are no economics to publish | not applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing, so there are no economics to publish | not applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing, so there are no economics to publish | we looked for it and it is not published |
Show the 16 checks they all score the same
Agreement is a finding too: where every program in a category fails the same check, that is the category’s norm rather than one vendor’s oversight.
| Check | Ashby | iCIMS | Greenhouse | Lever | Workday Recruiting |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A4 Rules of engagement | we looked for it and it is not published | we looked for it and it is not published | we looked for it and it is not published | we looked for it and it is not published | we looked for it and it is not published |
| A5 Changes dated | we looked for it and it is not published | we looked for it and it is not published | we looked for it and it is not published | we looked for it and it is not published | we looked for it and it is not published |
| B2 Shared pipeline | we looked for it and it is not published | we looked for it and it is not published | we looked for it and it is not published | we looked for it and it is not published | we looked for it and it is not published |
| B4 Funding | we looked for it and it is not published | we looked for it and it is not published | we looked for it and it is not published | we looked for it and it is not published | we looked for it and it is not published |
| C1 No entry fee | partly published | partly published | partly published | partly published | partly published |
| C2 No submission fee | partly published | partly published | partly published | partly published | partly published |
| C4 No annual fee | partly published | partly published | partly published | partly published | partly published |
| D1 Browsable directory | published, and we read it | published, and we read it | published, and we read it | published, and we read it | published, and we read it |
| D2 Earnable placement | we looked for it and it is not published | we looked for it and it is not published | we looked for it and it is not published | we looked for it and it is not published | we looked for it and it is not published |
| D3 Analytics returned | we looked for it and it is not published | we looked for it and it is not published | we looked for it and it is not published | we looked for it and it is not published | we looked for it and it is not published |
| E1 Price visible on the listing | not applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing, so there are no economics to publish | not applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing, so there are no economics to publish | not applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing, so there are no economics to publish | not applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing, so there are no economics to publish | not applicable by rule |
| F1 No exclusivity | partly published | partly published | partly published | partly published | partly published |
| F2 No broad IP grant | partly published | partly published | partly published | partly published | partly published |
| F3 No clone reservation | partly published | partly published | partly published | partly published | partly published |
| F4 Fair termination | partly published | partly published | partly published | partly published | partly published |
| F5 You keep the customer | partly published | partly published | partly published | partly published | partly published |