Skip to main content

Smart Displays & Speakers

2 qualifying programs compared.

Compare inside a category, not across the study. Two programs here face the same buyers and the same norms, so a difference between them means something. A difference between categories mostly measures the categories.

Axis scores for each program in Smart Displays & Speakers
AxisAmazon AlexaGoogle Nest
Overall69.06 axes42.35 axes
Transparency2.51.9
Demand2.01.0
Entry cost5.04.0
Distribution3.51.5
Economics5.0not applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing
Terms2.53.5

n/athe axis does not apply to that program — read it as “question not asked”, never as 0.

These programs are judged on different numbers of axes, so their totals are renormalized over different denominators and are not strictly comparable. The axis rows are.

Where they actually differ

17 of 30 checks diverge; 13 are identical across all 2
The checks on which these programs differ, with each program’s value
CheckAmazon AlexaGoogle Nest
A2 Requirements numericpartly publishedwe looked for it and it is not published
A3 Reward numericpublished, and we read itnot applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing, so there are no economics to publish
A5 Changes datedwe looked for it and it is not publishedpartly published
B4 Fundingpublished, and we read itwe looked for it and it is not published
C1 No entry feepublished, and we read itwe looked for it and it is not published
D2 Earnable placementwe looked for it and it is not publishedpartly published
D3 Analytics returnedpublished, and we read itwe looked for it and it is not published
D4 Listing controlpublished, and we read itwe looked for it and it is not published
D5 Audience disclosedpartly publishedwe looked for it and it is not published
E2 They collect and remitpublished, and we read itnot applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing, so there are no economics to publish
E3 You set the pricepublished, and we read itnot applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing, so there are no economics to publish
E4 Provisioning documentedpublished, and we read itnot applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing, so there are no economics to publish
E5 Payout terms publishedpublished, and we read itnot applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing, so there are no economics to publish
F2 No broad IP grantwe looked for it and it is not publishedpartly published
F3 No clone reservationpartly publishedpublished, and we read it
F4 Fair terminationpublished, and we read itwe looked for it and it is not published
F5 You keep the customerwe looked for it and it is not publishedpublished, and we read it
Show the 13 checks they all score the same

Agreement is a finding too: where every program in a category fails the same check, that is the category’s norm rather than one vendor’s oversight.

The checks on which every program in Smart Displays & Speakers scores the same, with each program’s value
CheckAmazon AlexaGoogle Nest
A1 Guide publicpublished, and we read itpublished, and we read it
A4 Rules of engagementwe looked for it and it is not publishedwe looked for it and it is not published
B1 Lead sharewe looked for it and it is not publishedwe looked for it and it is not published
B2 Shared pipelinewe looked for it and it is not publishedwe looked for it and it is not published
B3 Co-marketing specifiedwe looked for it and it is not publishedwe looked for it and it is not published
B5 Merchandisingpublished, and we read itpublished, and we read it
C2 No submission feepublished, and we read itpublished, and we read it
C3 Fast reviewpublished, and we read itpublished, and we read it
C4 No annual feepublished, and we read itpublished, and we read it
C5 No paid tier gatepublished, and we read itpublished, and we read it
D1 Browsable directorypublished, and we read itpublished, and we read it
E1 Price visible on the listingnot applicable by rulenot applicable — nothing can be sold through this listing, so there are no economics to publish
F1 No exclusivitypublished, and we read itpublished, and we read it